There is an urgent need to provide immediate and effective options for the treatment of prostate cancer (PCa) to prevent progression to lethal castration-resistant PCa (CRPC). The mevalonate (MVA) pathway is dysregulated in PCa, and statin drugs commonly prescribed for hypercholesterolemia, effectively target this pathway. Statins exhibit anti-PCa activity, however the resulting intracellular depletion of cholesterol triggers a feedback loop that restores MVA pathway activity, thus diminishing statin efficacy and contributing to resistance. To identify drugs that block this feedback response and enhance the pro-apoptotic activity of statins, we performed a high-content image-based screen of a 1508 drug library, enriched for FDA-approved compounds. Two of the validated hits, Galeterone (GAL) and Quinestrol, share the cholesterol-related tetracyclic structure, which is also evident in the FDA-approved CRPC drug Abiraterone (ABI). Molecular modeling revealed that GAL, Quinestrol and ABI not only share structural similarity with 25-hydroxy-cholesterol (25HC) but were also predicted to bind similarly to a known protein-binding site of 25HC. This suggested GAL, Quinestrol and ABI are sterol-mimetics and thereby inhibit the statin-induced feedback response. Cell-based assays demonstrated that these agents inhibit nuclear translocation of sterol-regulatory element binding protein 2 (SREBP2) and the transcription of MVA genes. Sensitivity was independent of androgen status and the Fluva-GAL combination significantly impeded CRPC tumor xenograft growth. By identifying cholesterol-mimetic drugs that inhibit SREBP2 activation upon statin treatment, we provide a potent "one-two punch" against CRPC progression and pave the way for innovative therapeutic strategies to combat additional diseases whose etiology is associated with SREBP2 dysregulation.