Lateral malleolar fractures are present in about 90% of ankle fractures. The standard treatment is plate osteosynthesis. Although the plates are thin, the risk of cicatricial complications is not insignificant and can lead to cutaneous or even infectious complications and the latter can cause functional repercussions. We therefore aimed to evaluate a technique consisting of osteosynthesis of the lateral malleolus using two cerclages and two intramedullary pins.

Our hypothesis is that the use of osteosynthesis by pin/cerclage of the lateral malleolus makes it possible to have objective reduction criteria, similar to the reference treatment.

This is a retrospective study of patients who had an interligamentous spiral fracture of the lateral malleolus. One group of patients had internal fixation of the lateral malleolus fracture by pins, and the other by plate. Our primary outcome was to compare the reduction of the fracture of the lateral malleolus between the two techniques using the “Dime sign”, the measurement of the talocrural angle and respect for Shenton's line.

A total of 118 lateral malleolar fractures were included: 56 patients (47.5%) in the “pin” group and 62 patients (52.5%) in the “plate” group. The mean age of the patients was 46.6 years (17.4) with an average body mass index of 25.2kg/m² (4.8) and 55.1% of the patients were women. We found a difference in the reduction criteria between the two groups by looking at Shenton's line: 73.2% (41/56) of postoperative X-rays in the “pin” group respected Shenton's line, compared to 90.3% (56/62) in the “plate” group (p=0.02). We did not find any difference regarding the “Dime sign” and the talocrural angle.

Our study shows the superiority of plate osteosynthesis for lateral malleolar fractures compared to pin/cerclage osteosynthesis, regarding one of the three radiological criteria for reduction. No significant difference was found in the one-year rates of complications and of hardware removal, between the two groups.

IV, retrospective study.