Since the 1940s, the importance of addressing polio survivors’ psychological issues along with their physical needs has been known. The clinical literature and polio survivors’ narratives indicate positive responses to both psychotherapy and psychologically informed medical care for issues connected with acute polio and rehabilitation experiences as well as post-polio syndrome. Yet, barriers in the form of stigma and lack of awareness and resources prevent most from accessing such care. This article addresses the provision of polio-informed psychological treatment as well as ways of creating a culture that supports mental health within medical settings.